Thursday, March 31, 2011

Important New SEC Ruling Offers Diversified Shareholder Responses To Corporate Election Spending

Sanford Lewis,  Attorney

Shareholders have won the right to seek an annual proxy review and vote on a company's  political spending, as a result of a new SEC decision. The SEC Staff, for the first time, allowed a shareholder resolution seeking shareholders' say on political spending (in a decision known as a “no action letter”).  The proposal will appear on the Spring 2011 proxy of the Home Depot.  The decision opens new options for shareholders seeking to take action in the aftermath of Citizens United,  portending diversified approaches to shareholder interventions beyond the predominant approach of seeking better disclosure.

Corporate Spending In Elections:  A Crisis Of Legitimacy
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, the controversial Supreme Court   “corporate free speech” decision in January of 2010, opened the floodgates to additional corporate  spending  in the political process, including  corporate funding of political advertising for and against candidates up to the day of an election. A baseline issue is the legitimacy of any corporate involvement and spending in the political process. The argument that giant corporations have essentially the same free speech rights in the political process as individuals, or even as groups of individuals, has met with enormous outrage and concern. A corporation is not a mere group of individuals  but a legally created moneymaking machine, and as such will warp our political process to the extent it is allowed to be a player.   

            Compare this with a recent Supreme Court decision, ATT v. FCC,  finding that corporations do not merit the same level of “privacy” protection as individuals, and the underlying notion of a corporation's participation in politics as if it were a "person" or "group of persons" is even more incongruous. 

Potential Interventions by Shareholders
Although this author believes more extensive reforms are needed to undo the damage to our political system caused by Citizens United, it also seems possible that shareholders could help rein in the worst abuses of companies in the new post Citizens United political environment.  The proposal cleared by SEC staff and filed by the Boston-based NorthStar Asset Management  (hereafter NorthStar)  asks the Board of Directors of  Home Depot  to annually include in its proxy statement the company’s policies on  political contributions,  a report on spending  for the past year, and anticipated spending for the next year. Shareholders would then vote on whether they support those policies and plans. In addition, NorthStar recommended in its proposal that the proxy also analyze whether the spending is  consistent with  the company’s values  and whether it poses risks to  the company’s brand, reputation, or shareholder value.

 In the aftermath of Citizens United,  companies can put corporate money into ads supporting candidates, even if the company’s own shareholders might support different candidates. There is little accountability for this spending.  One successful approach until now has been for shareholders to  file resolutions seeking better disclosure of corporate political spending.  This approach has been successfully advocated by numerous investors and the Center for Political Accountability.

However, now the specifics of spending on particular candidates and issues,  issues regarding risks to the company's reputation, and congruency of that spending with the company's stated values are also also fair game for debate on the proxy, culminating in a shareholder vote on those policies.  Home Depot had argued to the SEC that a vote on company spending would involve an impermissible intrusion of shareholders on the “ordinary business” of the Company. 

The company’s Senior Counsel Stacey Ingram asserted “Decisions as to the appropriate future recipients of the Company's political contributions are ordinary business decisions made by management as part of its day-to-day operation of the Company…. The ability to make such decisions is fundamental to in spending ability to control the operations of the Company and, as such, is not appropriately delegated to shareholders.”  However, under SEC and judicial precedents, shareholder proposals which present a “significant social policy issue” are not excludable even if they may otherwise intrude on ordinary business.  In ruling in favor of allowing the proposal, the staff has essentially determined that after  Citizens United, corporate political spending is a significant social policy issue and shareholders  can seek to have  input on management’s decisions. This contrasts with prior staff decisions finding that corporate charitable spending in general is excluded from shareholder oversight.

NorthStar  has particular concerns  about the failure of  Home Depot’s political spending to live up to its policy  against discrimination on account of  sexual orientation. Home Depot's disclosed PAC contributions include donations to candidates whose actions and opinions seemed adverse to  that policy. The financial and reputation risks associated with political spending were highlighted last year when the Target Company became the subject of a boycott campaign as a result of their support of anti-gay rights candidates.
 
Home Depot is cited on the Center for Political Accountability website as a "corporate leader" because the company discloses certain information and have adopted policies advocated by the Center. 

With the SEC decision,  the annual corporate meeting process can now become a battleground, not only on disclosure of spending, but also the financial risks to the company from that spending,  the congruency of  the spending with a company's stated values, and with investors' interests both as shareholders and as citizens. Ultimately, shareholders could vote on whether they support the management's practices.

 The Opening for Diverse Approaches
 The Home Depot proposal cleared by the SEC is only one possible approach to addressing congruency, risks and shareholder approval processes related to corporate electioneering.  The significance of the decision is that it opens the way for many similar approaches to be explored by shareholders  in future proposals.

The  NorthStar resolution  allowed by the SEC would give shareholders  a nonbinding, advisory vote seeking approval of a majority of shareholders on the company’s spending. In contrast, legislation pending in Congress would make shareholders’ vote  to approve corporate political spending binding on the company.

One serious limitation of  seeking a shareholder vote is that a majority of institutional investors typically support whatever the management of a company thinks is appropriate. Simply establishing shareholder approval processes in the proxy may merely allow a rubberstamping of the management's political predilections. In contrast, citizen investors, and others who may represent only a minority of  a corporation's investors may represent a dissenting view–not wanting to see their political preferences as citizens overridden by their investments–and yet be unable to block the spending. Harvard Law Professor Lucian Bebchuk has argued that to protect the rights of dissenting shareholders, requirements for a supermajority (e.g. 75% ) vote in favor of election spending could be appropriate.

            May shareholder responses to corporate money in the political process go forth and multiply.   In the aftermath of Citizens United, we need all the experimentation and engagement that's possible to staunch the bleeding.

 ---
Sanford Lewis is an Attorney who represented NorthStar Asset Management Funded Pension Plan before the SEC in defense of the Home Depot proposal.

20 comments:

Marcy Murninghan said...

However limited this ruling may appear, it's a giant step for American democracy. Let's hope that digital tools can amplify its impact to a wider public that generally feels powerless in the face of big money and deep pockets.

Congratulations to you, Sanford, and the folks at NorthStar Asset Management for so tirelessly defending the right to self-governance.

Marcy Murninghan.

sewa mobil jakarta said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.

Unknown said...

Thnx for taking the time to talk about this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more info? It is highly helpful for me. Two thumb up for this article!
Dirk Kettlewell

SEO Melbourne said...

Nice article, I like it!

rumah minimalis said...

However limited this ruling may appear, it's a giant step for American democracy. Let's hope that digital tools can amplify its impact to a wider public that generally feels powerless in the face of big money and deep pockets.


Tour Singapore Murah
Jual Gildan Kualitas Terbaik
Jual sablon kaos murah
Harga terupdate handphone

valqis.com said...

salah satu Desain Rumah Minimalis Terbaru yang terbaik ada di kelapa gading adalah dokter mobil, kami mempunyai kesempatan yang menarik dan inin menjadi salah sat terbaik untuk anda Service AC Mobil

crystal x said...

Rumah Minimalis | hajar Jahanam

Anonymous said...

salah satu Desain Rumah Minimalis Terbaru yang terbaik ada di kelapa gading adalah dokter mobil, kami mempunyai kesempatan yang menarik dan inin menjadi salah sat terbaik untuk anda Service AC Mobil salah satu webste terbaik di indonesia Crystal X

Obat Wasir said...

obat kemaluan keluar nanah pusat herbal obat kemaluan keluar nanah pusatnya obat herbal obat untuk kemaluan yang keluar nanah dan perih saat kencing pengobatan herbal denature indonesia obat kemaluan keluar cairan nanah dan perih saat kencinginformasi herbal denature
obat kemaluan keluar nanah pusat herbal obat kemaluan keluar nanah pusatnya obat herbal obat untuk kemaluan yang keluar nanah dan perih saat kencing pengobatan herbal denature indonesia obat kemaluan keluar cairan nanah dan perih saat kencinginformasi herbal denature
your site very inspiration and informatif obat ambeyen ibu hamil obat herbal penderita wasier mengatasi ambeyen dengan obat herbal cara mengobati wasir atau ambien herbal ampuh penyakit ambeien obat hemorrhoid atau ambeyen tanpa obat wasier tanpa operasi obat wasier ampuh obat penyakit ambien pada pria pengobatan wasir atau ambeien obat wasir atau ambeien parah obat wasir luar obat wasir atau ambeien alami obat wasir ampuh obat wasir berdarah obat wasir alami obat wasir tradisional pengobatan wasir atau hemoroid ciri ciri wasir obat wasir herbal ampuh

Anonymous said...

salah satu AC Mobil yang terbaik ada di kelapa gading adalah dokter mobil, kami mempunyai kesempatan yang menarik dan inin menjadi salah sat terbaik untuk anda Jual Hajar Jahanam

Properti Indonesia said...

Hi my friend! I wish to say that this post is amazing, nice written and include approximately all important infos. I would

like to read this. Melacak Genteng bocor

langsingslim said...

Cara Diet Alami Sehat dan Cepat
Manfaat dan Harga Glucogen
Genie Bra (Pakaian Dalam Wanita) Murah
Lixiao Obat Jerawat
Meilibahenling Original Penghilang Bekas Luka

langsingslim said...

Kapsul Biolo Obat Pelangsing Alami
Kapsul Biolo Obat Pelangsing Alami
Jamu Susut Perut Paling Ampuh
Kapsul Jamu Singset Alami

iklan gratis said...

It's very informative post, thanks a lot.

ana said...

Class College Education training Beauty teaching university academy lesson teacher master student spa manager skin care learn eyelash extensions tattoo spray

daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet
daythammynet

KUBET said...

KUBET được cộng đồng cá cược đánh giá là nhà cái số 1 Châu Á trong năm 2019 hiện tại. Với nhiều trò chơi hấp dẫn, tỷ lệ cược cực cao, trải nghiệm mượt mà mang tới cơ hội kiếm tiền cho anh em. KUBET.IO là trang web cung cấp link đăng ký, đăng nhập KU BET - KU CASINO chính thức, hướng dẫn hội viên tham gia các trò cá cược trên nhà cái, cũng như cách nạp tiền, rút tiền.



Từ khóa: #ku, #kubet, #kucasino, #kubetio, #ku777, #ku888, #ku999, #casino, #thienhabet, #kubetcasino



Mạng xã hội KUBET chính thức:


https://infogram.com/dang-ky-kubet-cach-tao-lap-tai-khoan-ku-bet-don-gian-1h8j4xglr0od6mv

https://trello.com/kubet

https://block-x.co/dang-ky-kubet/

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyPQbqZIZKV60Q7njSmKe3A


https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/S5X7VBD


Website: Kubet.io



Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng said...

Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng

Free JAV said...

JAVPRO - Jav Free, Jav Streaming, Jav Uncensored, Jav Censored, Jav Online. All clips JAVPRO was collecting from other websites sources, we wont able to copyright any countries. JAVPRO.CC will updates all for new videos.
Website: https://getpocket.com/@javprocc
Key: #jav , #javpro, #javpro.cc, #javhd, #javhdstreaming

Thiết Kế Nhà Đẹp Mới said...


Thietkenhadepmoi.vn - công ty thiết kế nhà đẹp uy tín. Thiết kế nhà - thiết kế nhà đẹp mới - thiết kế thi công nhà đẹp - thiết kế xây dựng nhà đẹp - mẫu nhà đẹp mới. Tổng hợp các mẫu nhà mái thái đẹp - mẫu nhà phố đẹp - mẫu biệt thự đẹp sang trọng.
Liên hệ ngay với công ty Thiết kế nhà đẹp mới để được tư vấn và báo giá miễn phí!

Từ khóa thiết kế nhà đẹp mới :
#thietkenhadepmoi #thietkenhadepmoivn #thietkennha #thietkennhadep #maunhadepmoi #thietkennhadepmoi #thietkennhauytin #maubietthudep #maunhamaithaidep #mauthietkenhadep #thietkexaydungnhadep #maunhaphodep #congtythietkenhadep #thietkethicongnhadep #thietkexaydungnhadep #maunhadepmoi #maunhamoi #xaydungnhadep #congtynhadep

https://visual.ly/users/thietkenhadepmoivn/portfolio
https://www.zoimas.com/profile/thietkenhadepmoivn
https://www.woddal.com/thietkenhadepmoivn
https://pawoo.net/@thietkenhadepmoivn
https://player.me/thiekenhadepmoivn/about

Website: Thietkenhadepmoi.vn

English Tivi said...

Englishtivi.com is a free website for English learners. You can improve your English story, vocabulary words, grammar, sentences, speaking, writing, idioms …. Thousands of English videos and lessons are waiting for you.
That's why, this website was founded with a simple vision: To become your go-to resource to Improve Your English Skills | Help You Change Your Life!
Official website: englishtivi.com
https://sites.google.com/view/englishtivi
https://trello.com/englishtivi
#Englishtivi
#Englishtv
#englishtiviyoutube
#englishtivionline
#englishtivilevel3
#englishtivilevel1
#learnenglishthroughstory
#learnenglishthroughstories